Решение от 21 декабря 2009 г. Верховный Суд РФ

""""

BEPXOBHbIMCYLI:POCCIIHCKOHELl:EPAUHHPEllIEHHEx!!BKTIU09-135I1MeHeMPOCCMHCKOH
ropoztMOCKBa «21»nexafips2009rona

BOeHHa5lKOJIJIerH5lBepxosnoroCynaPOCCHRCKORe,il,epaUHHBCOCTaBe npencenarenscrsyromero - cynsaBepxosnoroCyzia POCCHikKOR <1>e,il,epaUHH ConosseaaA.H.,npacexperape,ll,eHbry6E.Il.,Cy4acTHeMcrapurerosoeaaoro npoxypopaynpaaneaasrnaBHOHBoeHHOHnpoxyparypunonKOBHHKaIOCTHUHH ITaHrHHa P.X.,a TaK)I(e npencrasareneiiIlpanarem.craaP<1> - COBeTHHKa IOpH):(HqeCKOrOornenaa):(MHHHcTpaTHBHo-npaBoBoro,ll,errapTaMeHTaMHHHcTepcTBa perHOHaJIbHOrOpa3BHTH5lP<1>AKOn5lHr.JI.HxoacynsraaraorztenaHopMaTHBHo- rrpaaosoroofiecncseaaa,ll,errapTaMeHTarocynapcrseaaoa)l(HnHIl(HOHrronHTHKH YKa3aHHOrO MHHHCTepCTBaHcaesoiiO.B., MHHHcTepcTBa IOCTHUHH P<1> - 3aMeCTJnemI HaqaJIbHHKa orztena rro 06I.IJ;HM rrOnO)l(eHH5lM rpascnaacxoro 3aKOHO,il,aTenbCTBa,ll,errapTaMeHTarpazcztancxoroHCOUHaJIbHOrO3aKOHO,il,aTenbCTBa MHHIOcTaPOCCHHCBeTnHqHOHC.H.,paccaorpesBO:rKpbITOMcynetinovsacenanan rpazcnaacxoe zteno rro 3a5lBneHHIO HnbMeHeHKHHaIlB 0 rrpH3HaHHHa63.2n.2,n.6nocraaonneanaIlpaaarenscrsaPOT4,il,eKa6p5l2008 rona.M~902«0MepaxrrocTHMynHpoBaHHIOpsnnca)l(HnHI.IJ;HOrOcrpoarenscrsaB 2008-2009ronax»Hnozm.ca»n.l«IlpanannpaofipereaasB2008-2009ronax xaaprnpBMHoroKBapTHpHbIX):(OMax,il,mlnoennocnyacanraxHrpaxnan,ysonennsix CBoeHHOHcnysefisr»,yrnepzcztemrsrx,il,aHHbIMrrOCTaHOBneHHeM,He,il,eRcTBYIOI.IJ;HMH,

.'",'"

nocxonsxyOHHnporaaopesarCT.CT.3,4,a63.12rr.lcT.15<1>e):(epaJIbHOrO3aKOHa«0 crarycesoeaaocnyacantax»OT27Ma5l1998ronaN~76-<1>3Hq.1CT.51)l{HnHI.IJ;HOrO xoztescaP,

YCTAHOBI1JIA:

06paI.IJ;mICbBBepXOBHbIRCynP<1>CYKa3aHHbIM3a5lBneHHeM,HnbMeHeRKHH CqMTaeTqTO,ocnapasaensreMMHOPMbIrrOCTaHOBneHH5lJIpaaarenscrsaP<1>OT4 ):(eKa6p512008ronaN~902rrpHMeHHMbIBOTHoweHHHsoeaaocnyxaunrx,COCT05lI.IJ;MX aayxereBxasecrseHY)l():(aIOm~1XC5IB)l(HnbIXnOMeI.IJ;eHH5IXnonocnezmexrynepen YBonbHeHHeMMecTyBoeHHoRcny)l(6bI.

IToMHeHHIO3a5lBMTen5l,ztaanaaQlopMynHpoBKaorpanasnsaereronpasa,KaK HeCOCT05lIl(erOnaysereHy)l(.naIOIl(MXC5lBnonyseaaa)l(MnbIXnOMeI.IJ;eHMRrroMecTy cnyzctisr,HOy-rrenaoroBcnacxaxrpaaoian,H3b5lBHBWMX»cenaaneztnsnepeuem.r MeCTa)l(MTenbCTBaBnopsnxerrepecenenaaM3aaxpsrrorosoenaororopoznca.



-----------

'1,;

1)6

2
I1JIbMeHeHKI1H nonaraer, qTO OCHOBHbIM xparepnexr .n.JI5I npaaenenns nOCTaHOBJIeHI1$1I1paBI1TeJIbCTBaP<1> OT4ztexafip»2008 ronaN2902BCBeTe Tpe60BaHI1H CT.CT.3,4,a63.12 n.l cT.15 <1>e.n.epaJIbHOrO 3aKOHa «0 craryce BOeHHOCJIY)l(ar.u:l1x»11-r.IcT.51)l{I1JII1W:HoroxonexcaP<1>$IBJI$leTC$IHY)l(.n.aeMocTb rpazcnananaB)l(I1JIOMnOMew:eHI1I1,I1HoeTOJIKOBaHl1esenerKHapyweHI1IOe.n.I1HCTBa CI1CTeMbInpaaosoii11COUl1aJIbHOH3ar.u:I1TbIBOeHHOCJIY)l(aW:l1x.

Ocnapnaas3aKOHHOCTbn.6BbIllleYKa3aHHOrOnOCTaHOBJIeHI151I1paBI1TeJIbCTBa P<1>,3a$lBI1TeJIbyxaasrsaer,qTOI1paBI1TeJIbCTBOP<1>HeI1MeJIOnpaBOMOql1Hrtopyxars MI1HI1CTepCTBY060POHbIP<1>COBMeCTHOC.n.pyrl1MI1MI1HI1CTepCTBaMI1nonrorosxy npoexra axra,pernaaearupyioureronopanox npl13HaHI151 BOeHHOCJIY)KaW:l1x HY)l(.n.aIOW:I1MI1C5IB)KI1JIbIXnOMer.u:eHI151X11nopsnoxnpe.n.OCTaBJIeHI15111M)Kl1nbIX nOMer.u:eHI1HBc06CTBeHHOCTb6eCnJIaTHO.

B B03pa)l(eHI151X aa 3a5lBJIeHI1e npe.n.CTaBI1TeJII1 I1paBI1TeJIbCTBaP<1> 11 MI1HI1CTepCTBa IOCTI1UI1I1 P<1> npOCI1JII1 B y.n.OBJIeTBOpeHI1I1 Tpe60BaHI1H I1JIbMeHeHKI1HaOTKa3aTb.~

B CB5I311 Cxo.n.aTaHCTBOM 3a5lBI1TeJI$I, nannescameasaeuieanoro0 ztare, BpeMeHI111MeCTecynefinorosacenanaa,rpaacnancxoe.n.eJIOCyxeroaMHeHI1$IJII1IJ" yqaCTBYIOr.u:I1XBztene,paCCMOTpeHOBeroOTCyTcTBl1e.

I1pe.n.CTaBlfTeJII1I1paBI1TeJIbCTBaP<1>AKOIDIHr.JI.,HcaesaO.B.,aTaK)Ke MI1HI1CTepCTBa IOCTHUI1I1 P<1> CBeTJII1QHa$l C.H. B cyzte B03pa)l(aJIM npOTI1B y.n.OBJIeTBOpeHWI TPe60BaHMH I1JIbMeHeHKMHa, 3a51BMB, QTO a63.2 n.2, n.6 nOCTaHOBJIeHM$II1paBMTeJIbCTBaP<1>OT4ziexatipa2008roztaN2902«0Mepaxno cTMMyJIMpOBaHMIO psraxa )l(MJIMr.u:Horo cTPoMTeJIbCTBa B2008-2009 ronax» M nonn.ea» n.l «I1paBMJI npl106peTeHM$I B 2008 - 2009 ronax xaaprnp B MHoroKBapTMpHbIX.n.OMax.n.JI$IBOeHHOCJIy)l(ar.u:MXMrpaacnaa,YBOJIeHHbIXCBoeHHOH CJIy)l(6bI»,YTBep)l(.n.eHHbIX.n.aHHbIMnOCTaHOBJIeHMeM,HenpOTMBOpeQaTCT.CT.3,4, a63.12n.lcT.15<1>e.n.epaJIbHOrO3aKOHa«0craryceBOeHHOCJIy)l(aW:Mx»OT27Ma51 1998ronaN276-<1>3Mnpas3a5lBMTeJI$IHeaapymator.

HccnenosasMaTepMaJIbI ztena, BbIcnyIIIaB 06'b$lCHeHI1$I npeztcraaarencii I1paBMTeJIbCTBaP<1>, MMHI1CTepCTBaIOCTMIJ,MMP<1> M3aKJIIOQeHMe npoxypopa, norrarasmeroHe06xo.n.MMbIMBy.n.oBJIeTBOpeHMMTPe60BaHMH3a5lBMTeJIIOOTKa3aTb, BoeHHa5IKOJIJIerM$IBepxosaoroCynaP<1>rrpaxomrrKcJIe.n.YIOr.u:I1MBblBo.n.aM.

COrJIaCHO a63.12 n.l cT.15 e.n.epaJIbHOrO 3aKOHa «0 craryce BOeHHOCJIy)l(ar.u:Mx»OT27Ma5I1998roztaN276-3BOeHHOCJIy)l(ar.u:HM-rpaaczranaa, 06eCneQMBaeMbIM na sees CpOK BoeHHOH cny)l(6bI CJIy)l(e6HbIMM )l(MJIbIMM nOMer.u:eHM$lMM H npM3HaHHbIM HY)l(.n.alOr.u:MMI1C$I B )l(I1JIbIX 1I0Mer.u:eHM5IX B COOTBeTCTBMMcoCTaTbeH51)l(MJIMr.u:HoroxonexcaPOCCMMCKOMe.n.epaUMI1,110 .n.OCTM)I(eHMM06r.u:eHIIPO.n.OJI)KI1TeJIbHOCTMBoeHHoHCJIy)l(6bI20JIeTM60JIee,aIIpM YBOJIbHeHMMCBoeHHOMCJIy)l(6bIno.n.OCTM)I(eHMHHMHnpcnensaorosospacra IIpe6blBaHI1$1na BoeHHOHcnyxtie,no COCT05lHI11O 3.n.0POBb51 I1JIM BCB5I311 C opraHM3aIJ,MOHHO-lllTaTHbIMH MepOllpM$lTM5I:MH IIpM 06r.u:eH IIp0)l,On)l(MTeJIbHOCTI1 BoeHHOH CJIy)l(6bI 10 ner H fionee IIpe)l,OCTaBJI5I:IOTC5I: )KMJIble nOMew:eHI151, HaXO)l,5I:r.u:HeC5I:Be.n:epaJIbHOMc06cTBeHHocTM,noBbI60pyYKa3aHHblXrpaxcnanB c06cTBeHHocTb 6eCnJIaTHO Ha OCHOBaHMM peWeHI151: e.n:epaJIbHOrO opraHa HCnOJIHMTeJIbHOHBJIaCTH,BKOTOpOMrrpenycnorpenaBOeHHa51:cnyzctia,HJII1110zioroaopy COll,l1aJIbHOrO HaHMa C YKa3aHHbIM cPe.uepaJIbHbIM OpraHOM I1CrrOJIHI1TeJIbHOHBJIaCTl1rro1136paHHoMyrrOCTO}lHHOMYMecTy)Kl1TeJIbCTBal1B COOTBeTCTBl111 C HOpMaMI1 rrpe.uOCTaBJIeHI1}1 nnouiana )KI1JIOrO nosremenus, npenycaorpenuuwacrarseti15.1aacrosutero<1>e.uepaJIbHOrO3aKOHa.Ilopsnox rrpl13HaHI1}1YKa3aHHbIXnauHY)K.ualOllJ,l1Ml1C5IB)KI1JIbIXrrOMellJ,eHl151Xl1nopsnox rrpe.uOCTaBJIeHI1}1 11M )Kl1JIbIX rrOMellJ,eHI1H B C06CTBeHHOCTb 6eCrrJIaTHO onpenensrorcsnpaBl1TeJIbCTBOMPOCCI1HCKOH<1>e.u:epall,l1l1.

TaKI1M 06pa30M, ztamrax HOpMa YKa3bIBaeT 0 npase BOeHHOCJIy)KallJ,l1X, rrpl13HaHHbIX HY)K.uaIOllJ,l1Ml1C5I B )l(I1JIbIX rrOMellJ,eHl151X, rrOJIYI.Il1Tb )Kl1JIbe B co6CTBeHHOCTb6eCrrJIaTHOI1JIl1no.uorOBopyCOll,l1aJIbHOrOHaHManol136paHHoMy MecTy )l(I1TeJIbCTBa.Ilopsnox)l(e peanaaannn .uaHHoH HOPMbI npennacaao onpenemrrsnpaBI1TeJIbCTBYP.

llOCTaHOBJIeHl1e npaBl1TeJIbCTBa P OT 4 .ueKa6p}l 2008 rozta .N"Q902, OT.ueJIbHbIeHOPMbIxoroporoocnapasaer3MBl1TeJIb,113.uaHOHeBOI1CrrOJIHeHl1e a63.12n.lCT.15e.uepaJIbHOrO3aKOHa«0craryceBbeHHOCJIY)KallJ,l1x»,KaK3TO rrpezicraanaercaI1JIbMeHeHKI1HY,aBnenaxCTI1MYJIl1pOBaHI151psmxa)l(I1JIl1llJ,HOrO CTpOI1TeJIbCTBa1106eCrreqeHI1}1KBapTl1paMI1HeBcex,.aHeKOTopbIXxareropaii rpaaotaa,YCTaHOBJIeHHbIX3aKOHo.uaTeJIbCTBOM.

B COOTBeTCTBl111cocT.cT.13, 15,20e.uepaJIbHOrOKOHCTI1TYll,l10HHOrO 3aKoHa«0llpaBI1TeJIbCTBeP<1>>>OT17.ueKa6p}l1997rona,llpaBIUeJIbCTBOP<1> oCYllJ,eCTBJI5leTperynuposaaaeBCOll,l1aJIbHO-3KOHOMl1qeCKOHcdiepe,cPopMl1pyeT cPe.uepaJIbHbIeuenesuenporpaMMbIIiofiecrtexasaeraxpeanasaumo,aTaK)Ke 06eCneQl1BaeT acnonaeaae 61O.n;)I(eTa Iicouaansnsreraparrran .n;JI}I BOeHHOCJIy)l(allJ,l1x.

M3JIO)l(eHHOerr03BOJI}leTcnenarsBbIBO.n;0TOM,QTOliCXO.n;}I113cPl1HaHCOBbIX B03MO:>KHOCTeHrocynapcrsa11yCTaHOBJIeHHOrOKpaTKOCpOQHOrO.n;eHCTBl1}1(20082009ronsr)Ha3BaHHOrorrOCTaHOBJIeHli5l,IlpaaarenscrsoP,BbI.n;eJII1BKOHKpeTHbIe 06beMbIcPe.n;epaJIbHOrO6IO.n;)KeTaueneasmHa3HaQeHl1eM3Tl1XcpeztcrnBpaauepe 21.000Ml1JIJIl10Hapy6JIeHMI1HliCTepcTBY060POHbIPnaoficcncaenae)l(I1JIbeM BOeHHOCJIy)l(allJ,l1xIi 11.601 MI1JIJIliOHOBpy6JIeH.n;JI5Irpazcnan, YBOJIeHHbIX C BoeHHOH CJIy:>K6bI Ii QJIeHOB ax ceMeH,npezrycaorpearrstxna peaJIl13all,111O MepOnpM51TliHnonnporpaxoasr«BbIITOJIHeHlierocynapcrseaasrxo6513aTeJIbCTBno ofiecnesenarocPe.n;epaJIbHOHll,eJIeBOHnporpaMMbI«)KI1JII1llJ,e»na2002-2010rozrsr, 6blJIOsnpaseonpenenars,xaxaeliMeHHOKaTerOpl111BOeHHOCJIy)l(allJ,l1x11rpasotan, YBOJIeHHhIX C BoeHHOH CJIy)K6bI rrozmanaror non .n;eHCTBl1e npl151TOrO l1M HOpMaTI1BHOrO npasosoro axra, a TaK:>Ke YCTaHOBI1Tb Kpl1Tepl111 BbI60pa npaofiperaexnax:>KliJIbIXrrOMellJ,eHI1H,BTOMQliCJIeBQaCTI1axCTOI1MOCTI1,06llJ,eH nnoutazm:>KI1JIhIXrrOMellJ,eHI1HB3aBliCl1MOCTIiOTQI1CJIaKOMHaTBTaKI1Xxsaprapax, 06peMeHeHM5I I1X Pa3JII1QHOrO porta 06513aTeJIbCTBaMI1, I1HbIe yCJIOBl1}1, HeCOOTBeTCTBl1e KOTOpbIM I1CKJIIOQaeT B03MO)l(HOCTb rrpl106peTeHI1}1 )KI1JIbIX nouemeaati.

)l,aHHbIMnOCTaHOBJIeHl1eMTaK)I(eyrsepacnensr«npaBI1JIarrpI106peTeHl1}1B 2008-2009ronaxxsapnrpBMHorOKBapTlipHbIX.n;OMax.n;JI5IBOeHHOCJIy)l(allJ,I1Xl1 rpaxcnaa,YBOJIeHHbIXCBoeHHOHCJIy)l(6bI»,rroztrr.ea»n.lKOTOpbIXyxassraaer,QTO Ha3BaHHbIenpaBI1JIaonpenenstornopanoxnpl106peTeHI151MI1HI1CTepCTBoM060POHbI


n!

4
P<1> Ii nO)l,Be)l,OMCTBeHHbIM MIiHIiCTepCTBY pernouansuoro pa3BI1TH5I PeD
CCbInKa 3a5IB11TeJ15I na CT.CT.3, 4 eDe.n:epaJIbHOrO 3aKOHa «0 craryce eoeaaocnyxaurax»11na1.J.1cT.51 )KHnI1llI,HoroKO,II,eKCaP<1>,KOTOpbIM51K06bI npoTHBOpe1.JaTa63.2n.2nOCTaHOBneH115ITIpaB11TenbCTBaOT4,II,eKa6p512008rona NQ902Hrronn.ca»n.1 «TIpaBHn...»,yTBep)K,II,?HHbIX3THM)KenOCTaHOBJ1eH11eM, 5IBn5IeTC5I6eCnpe,II,MeTHoH.

YKa3aHHbIe3aKOHO,II,aTenbHbleHOPMbIonpenenaiorrapaHT1111npaaoaoii11 COll,HaJIbHOHsamarsrsoeaaocnyxcaunrx,rpaxnaa,YBoneHHbIXCBoeHHOHcny)K6bI,11 1.JneHOB HX ceMeH, npasoasre OCHOBbI craryca soennocnyzcanrax, OCHOBaHI151 npH3HaHH5IrpaxcraaHy)K)l;alOllI,HMHC5IB)KHnbIXnOMellI,eHH5IX,npe,II,OCTaBn5IeMbIXno ztorosopavCOll,HaJIbHOrOHaHMaHBnp5IMOHnOCTaHOBKeHeperynapyiorsonpocsr cTHMynHpoBaHH5Ipsnnca)KHnHllI,HOrOcrpoarenscrsaH06eCneQeHH5IKBapTI1paMHB MHorOKBapTHpHbIX,n;OMaxrpaacnan, YBoneHHbIXCBoeHHOHcnysfisr,KaK3TO ,II,eTaJIbHOnponacanoBYKa3aHHOMnOCTaHOBneHHHTIpaBHTenbCTBaP<1>.

TaKHM06pa30M,npHBe,II,eHHbIeHOPMbInOCTaHOBneHH5ITIpaBHTenbCTBaP<1>He COOTHOC5ITCj{HHCCT.CT.3,4Ha63.12n.1cr.lS<1>e.n:epaJIbHOrO3aKOHa«0craryce soeaaocnyacaurax», HH C If.1 CT.51 )KHnHllI,HOrO xonexca P<1>, H HM He npOTHBOpeQaT, nOCKonbKY He pernavearapyror nOp5I.n;OK npH3HaHI15I noemrocnyscaurax Hy)K,II,alOllI,HMHCj{ B )KHnbIX novemeaaxx H nopsnox npe.n;OCTaBJIeHHj{HM)KHnbIXnOMellI,eHHHBco6CTBeHHOCTbfiecnnaraoHnHno COll,HaJIbHOMYHaHMy.

qTO)KeKaCaeTC5InpasaaaBbI60pMeCTa)KHTenbCTBacaaorol1JIbMeHe:H:KHHa TI.B.,TOOHOnOCTaHOBneHHeMTIpaBHTenbCTBaP<1>OT4,II,eKa6pj{2008rO,II,aNQ902 TaK)Ke Hepernaaearapyercs,nOCKonbKY, KaK BH,II,HO H3 npe.n;CTaBJIeHHbIX MaTepHaJIOB,OHCOCTOI1TnaYQeTeHy)K,II,alOllI,HXC5IBOT,II,enbHbIXcnacxaxrpascaaa,

.'',

rronnezcanmxnepeceneamoH33aKpbITbIXBoeHHbIXrOpO,II,KOBBCOOTBeTCTBHHC nonn.efi»n.5«TIpaBHn...»,YTBep)K.n;eHHbIXnOCTaHOBneHHeMTIpaBHTeJIbCTBaPeDOT 21MapTa2006ronaNQ153.

YTBep)K.n;eHHe3a5IBHTeJI5I0He3aKOHHOCTHn.6nOCTaHOBneHH5IIlpaaarenscrsa P<1>OT4.n;eKa6p5I2008rO,II,aNQ902fieaocnonarensno.

BCOOTBeTCTBHHcocT.23<1>e.n;epaJIbHOrOKOHcTHTyll,HOHHOro3aKoHa«0 IlpaaarenscrscP<1>>>nOCTaHOBneHH5IHpacnOp5I)KeHH5IIlpasarenscrnaPOCCHHCKOH <1>e,II,epall,HH065I3aTenbHbIKHcnonHeHHIOBPOCCHHCKOH<1>e,II,epall,HH.

TIPH3TOM,COrJIaCHOn.9Hno.n:rr.30n.10«TIOJIO)KeHH5I0MHHHcTepcTBe 060POHbIP<1>>>,yTBep)K)l;eHHOrOYKa30MTIpe3H.n;eHTaP<1>OT16asrycra2004rO,II,a NQ1082,MI:iHHCrp060POHbIP<1>nO,II,1.JHH5IeTC5InenocpencraennoTIpe3H.n;eHTyP<1>H IlpeztceztaremoTIpaB11:TenbCTBaP<1>.OHnpe,II,CTaBn5IeTByCTaHOBJIeHHOMnOp5I,lJ,Ke npoexrsrepe,II,epaJIbHbIX3aKOHOB,aKTOBTIpe3H.n;eHTaP<1>HIlpasarenscraaP<1>no nonpocaxrCOll,HaJIbHOH3allI,11TbIsoenaocrryxcarnax,mrurpaaoiancxoronepconana BoopY)KeHHbIXCHn,rpasotaa,ysoneaasrxCBoeHHoHcny)K6bI,HqneHOBHXceveti.


{,c.}

.~...)

5
B3TOHCB~3HOCHOBaHHH~n~y~OBneTBOpeHH~Tpe60BaHHH3a~BHTen~He HMeeTC~.

HaOCHOBaHHHH3nO)l(eHHOrO,PYKOBO~CTBY~ChCT.CT. 194-198,252H253 I'pascnaacxoronpoueccyansaoroxonexca P<1>,BoennasxonnerasBepxosaoro CyziaPOCCHHCKOH<1>e~epal..(l-n1

PEIIH1J1A:

Bynoanersopeaaa3a~BneHH~I1nhMeHeHKHHanB\0 npH3HaHHHa63.2n.2,n.6nOCTaHOBneHH~IlpaaarenscraaP<1>OT4ncxaops2008 ronaN~902«0MepaxnocTHMyJIHpOBaHHJOpsmxa)l(HnHIl(HOrOcrponrem.crnaB 2008-2009roziax»Hnonn.ca»n.l«IlpasannpaooperenaaB2008-2009ronax

\
KBapTHpBMHoroKBapTHpHhIX.lI.OMa~.lI.nflsoemrocnyzcamaxHrpaxcaan,YBOJIeHHbIX CBoeHHoHcnyxtisr»,yrecpxncmmx~aHHbIMnOCTaHOBneHHeM,He.ll.eHcTBYJOmHMH Hnporasope-rautaxraCT.CT.3,4,a63.l2II.lcr.lf<1>e~epanbHoro3aKOHa«0craryce soeanocnyacaurax»OT27Ma~1998ronaN276-<1>3,q.lCiT.51)l{HnHIUHoroxonexca P<1>,-OTKa3aTh.

HapemerraeMO)l(eT6bIThnonanaKaCCaI..(HOHH~:>KMo6aBKaccal..(HOHHyJO xonrreraroBepxosnoroCynaPOCCHHCKbEJ<1>elIepal..(HHBreseuue~eC~TH~HeHco ~~eroBhIHeceHH~.I

..

CyzrssBepxosaoroCyzra

A.H.Conosses

POCCHHCKOH<1>e.ll.epal..(HH:.,'-01...-~

Суд:

Верховный Суд РФ (подробнее)

Судьи дела:

Соловьев Анатолий Иванович (судья) (подробнее)